Inclusive

Welcome, curious souls, to a topic that’s both fascinating and deeply personal: birthing location options. The journey of bringing a new life into the world is nothing short of miraculous, and the choices you make along the way can greatly impact the experience. In this blog, we’ll dive into the three primary options: hospitals, home birth, and birth centers. Each of these birthing location options hold pros and cons and understanding them can empower you to make an informed decision that resonates with your desires and values.

Hospital Births: It’s All About The Detail

Many hospitals and OB’s view birth as a medical process that needs to be managed and have every possible intervention readily available if needed. They are equipped to handle a range of birthing scenarios, from routine deliveries to complex medical situations.

Postpartum Essentials - a line art drawing of a baby being cradled with a parent's hand on their head with a very light pink background with peach water color circles and gold glitter accents

Care and Providers

In a hospital setting, you’ll be attended to by a team of medical professionals, including obstetricians, nurses, and anesthesiologists (if you need a cesarean section) and possibly a midwife if you are in a midwifery led unit or they have midwives on staff. If you have a high-risk pregnancy or medical conditions that require specialized attention, a hospital birth might be the best or only choice for you.

Pros:

  • Medical Expertise: Hospitals have advanced medical technology and highly trained professionals, making them the best choice for complicated pregnancies or potential complications during birth.

  • Emergency Care: If unforeseen complications arise, hospitals can provide immediate access to emergency interventions.

  • Pain Management Options: Hospitals offer pain relief options like epidurals, which can be beneficial for those seeking pain management during labor.

  • Peace of Mind: For parents who feel more secure with a medical safety net, the hospital environment offers reassurance.

Cons:

  • Medicalization: Some individuals feel that hospitals may lead to unnecessary interventions due to the medical environment’s standard procedures.

  • Less Personal Atmosphere: The clinical nature of hospitals might make it harder to create a cozy and intimate birthing environment.

  • Rigid Protocols: Hospital policies and routines might not align with certain preferences for birthing positions, movement, or atmosphere.

Home Birth Is All About a Personal and Familiar Experience

Home births are exactly what they sound like, having your baby in your own home. They have gained popularity among those who seek a more personal and intimate birthing experience.

Care and Providers:

Home births are often attended by certified professional midwives (CPMs), Licensed Midwives (LMs) or Certified Midwives (CMs). Certification and legality of midwives varies by state. These providers are trained to offer personalized care and support within the home or birth center environment.

Pros:

  • Familiar Surroundings: Being in a familiar space can enhance relaxation and potentially lead to a smoother labor experience.

  • Personalized Care: Home births typically involve a strong patient-provider relationship, with ample time for discussions and individualized birth plans.

  • Family Involvement: Family members can be more actively involved in the birthing process in the comfort of your home.

  • Limited Intervention Approach: For those who prefer minimal medical interventions, home births offer a setting that aligns with a more physiological birth process.

Cons:

  • Limited Medical Intervention: While home births can accommodate many scenarios, certain emergencies may require transfer to a hospital.

  • Pain Management Options: Home births have fewer medical pain relief options available compared to hospitals.

  • Emergency Response: In the event of unexpected complications, the time it takes to transfer to a hospital could be a concern.

Birth Centers Are All About Hospital Capabilities in Comfortable Environments

If you are not comfortable being at home, or do not have a home environment that is suitable for delivery due to things like size, privacy, etc. but you’d still like to stay out of the hospital, a free-standing birth center may be an option for you. 

There are two types of birth centers, freestanding and attached. Freestanding birth centers are individual buildings and businesses that usually have 3-5 birthing suites.

They are equipped with birthing tubs, showers, birthing equipment, beds, etc. and each suite often mimics a large hotel room or large bedroom.

They offer the same equipment as a home birth as they are attended by the same midwives as a home birth.  Many times they are located closer to a hospital in case a transfer is needed. 

An attached birth center or midwifery led unit, is often a birth center that is inside of a hospital.

It may be an entire floor dedicated to midwifery led care or it may be interspersed between other hospital rooms attended by OB’s. This type of birth center is usually staffed by certified nurse-midwives (CNMs) or CPMs.

These providers are skilled in offering holistic care with a focus on natural birthing practices, but often also hold a degree in nursing. The pros and cons of the attached birth center are much the same as a hospital.  For the purposes of the pros and cons below, we are referring to a freestanding birth center. 

Postpartum Essentials - a line art drawing of a mother and father cradling each other and a newborn on the father's shoulder with a beige background with green water color circle and gold glitter accents

Pros:

  • Homey Atmosphere: Birth centers provide a cozy setting that’s less clinical than hospitals, which can promote a sense of calm during labor but are not actually in your home.

  • Physiological Birthing Approach: Birth centers often prioritize birthing techniques that encourage pelvic birth, including movement, various birthing positions, and minimal interventions.

  • Medical Readiness: While birth centers have the same medical supplies and equipment on hand as midwives who attend home births, they are commonly located close to a hospital so they may quickly address complications or the need to transfer.

  • Family-Friendly: Birth centers typically welcome family involvement and provide a comfortable space for partners and loved ones.

Cons:

  • Limited Interventions: Birth centers have fewer medical interventions available compared to hospitals.

  • Transfer Possibility: Just like with home births, some emergencies might require a transfer to a hospital for specialized care.

Choose Between Hospital, Home Birth or a Birth Center, What’s Right for You?

As you embark on this incredible journey, remember that there is no one-size-fits-all answer. The birthing location you choose should reflect your values, desires, and any medical considerations. Engage in open conversations with your chosen support people, explore your feelings about each birthing location, and envision the type of environment in which you feel most empowered and safe to bring your baby into the world.

Whether you opt for a hospital, your home, or a birth center, the magic of childbirth remains a constant. Your strength and love will guide you through, regardless of the path you choose. May your birthing experience be a beautiful and transformative chapter in your life’s story.

Skip to content